December 20, 2009

UPDATED: Consultants or equipment for Racine's cable-access station?

Update 2: We learned more about CAR25's future on Monday night. The Finance and Personnel Committee voted unanimously to use $30,000 set aside in the 2009 budget for a part-time employee that was never hired to help the cable-access channel move into a larger office in the City Hall Annex. (CAR25 is now in the Annex's basement.) The move will start on Jan. 4.

What remains unclear is how extra money in CAR25's 2010 budget will be used. One idea is to buy equipment to tie the station into the AT&T Uverse package, which would also allow the city to stream CAR25 online and broadcast live from the City Hall. Another idea is to use the money to hire a consultant to create programming for CAR25.

Update:
Here's a few more specifics on CAR25's budget. The city budgeted $80,860 for CAR25 in 2009. That number jumped to $115,903 in 2010. The bulk of the increase came under "operating expenditures," which jumped from $4,125 in 2009 to $44,375 in 2010. "Inter-Departmental" costs increased from $8,618 in 2009 to $14,500 in the 2010 budget. To offset some of the increase, "Salaries & Fringe Benefits" were cut from $67,891 in 2009 to $57,028 in the 2010 budget.

Original: CAR25 is getting attention from city leaders.

At issue is how to spend an additional $35,000 in the cable access station's 2010 budget. The money came from allocating an additional 5 percent from the city's telecommunications franchise fee paid by cable TV subscribers.

We're told some would like to use the money to hire consultants to create new programming for the station. The mayor's budget proposal alluded to this by suggesting the additional money will be used to pay for informational videos regarding "water, parks, streets, fire, police, health and other matters of public concern."

Insiders tell us the new programming would be used to hire consultants to create the informational videos. But some are skeptical. They'd rather see the money used to buy new equipment, tie the station into AT&T's cable system (CAR25 is currently unavailable to AT&T subscribers) and create the ability for live CAR25 broadcasts (for example, to broadcast City Council meetings).

Some are also worried about past efforts to hire consultants for CAR25. Former Mayor Gary Becker spent $30,000 on consultants with little to show for the money, according to insiders.

So the debate appears to center around spending the money on consultants or equipment for CAR25. Look for a decision to be made on the money in the next few weeks. The city's Cable TV Commission meets Jan. 18 and we're told a decision will be made before that meeting.

40 comments:

  1. This channel is a great addition to this city and has been for the past few years. It's free to the community and does NOT cost taxpayers a DIME! The channel already plays those videos proposed. Sounds like the mayor is proposing hiring one of his buddys! This is the community's channel, NOT THE MAYORS! This money should rightfully go to community to fund the channel and it's equipment NOT THE MAYOR!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Wrong, anon 7:08

    "The money came from allocating an additional 5 percent from the city's telecommunications franchise fee paid by cable TV subscribers."

    So they used money that we pay to Time Warner, that could be used for any purpose by the city, including reducing the need to tax us further - or, how about eliminating the franchise fee on Time Warner, which is nothing but another tax on Racine taxpayers.

    ReplyDelete
  3. How about just hire an out of work vdeographer part-time. Put people back to work

    ReplyDelete
  4. Very Wrong, Anon 7:29

    You surely understand NOT everyone has TW Cable, thus, many many taxpayers are not paying a dime. That means it's the people who choose TW, NOT the average taxpayer that pay for TW. By the way i think the channel is just fine now. If a consultant is approved, it will surely have to be bid out in this city correct? Or is Dickert going to try and hire his personal friend or realative??? Watch this one closely Dustin!

    ReplyDelete
  5. How about returning the 5% to the people paying the fees and say the hell with CAR25?

    ReplyDelete
  6. Is $35,000 below the level that would require the city to put it out to bid? It could be a no bid contract.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I'll give CAR25 some free "consulting" -- fire the prom and 4th of July hosts. Both did terrible!

    ReplyDelete
  8. Actually it does cost the taxpayers, anything that is missing is made up by the IT budget. Also the city pays to house the office at the city hall annex. What I don't understand is how some of the unpatriotic garbage shown on there help the city.

    ReplyDelete
  9. The franchise fee brings $700,000 in to the city annually. CAR25 sees a small portion of that.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Companies don't pay taxes - whether you call it a tax, or a franchise fee, it is a tax - and like all taxes levied on companies, it is passed on to consumers.

    Government uses this kind of subterfuge, because they know that if the taxpayers were aware of exactly how much of their money were going to feed the insatiable beast that is government, there would be a taxpayer revolt.

    ReplyDelete
  11. This channel is the community channel, it belongs to all of us who wish to take part. It does NOT belong to Dickert who just wants to use it for political gain and to try and get re-elected. Screw Dickert and his cronies.

    ReplyDelete
  12. The franchise fee is just another way for government to get into your pocket and expand its realm.
    If we cut out the franchise fee we would cut out that much more pork and temptation for special interest groups.
    Why not have the Racine car dealers pay a business fee that goes to support the bus system?
    Or every home owner pay a fee (to be administered by some city union member employee) that goes to support homeless shelters?

    ReplyDelete
  13. Hey Dickert read the article, Becker tried this and it was a huge failure! Purchase the equipment for the community and to hell with a consultant.

    ReplyDelete
  14. I continue to be amazed by the number of people that don't realize a fee that is paid to the government is a tax even if it is a corporation that is collecting it. The cable and phone companies historically collect government fees that are passed on to the government after they take their share for collecting the fee.

    The latest state budget is full of fee increases and new fees yet the dems bragged that the didn't increase taxes. The fees they increased are still taxes as long as the money comes from your pocket.

    Washington will likely pay for their run away spending with a combination of fees and taxes that will all come out of our pockets.

    ReplyDelete
  15. CAR25 already produces videos for police, fire, water, health and other departments, along with all city council meetings. They need new equipment for public producers to use to improve their programming and give more access to more people. The City paid over $20,000 to an outside consultant for promotional videos about 2 years ago, which were a complete disaster and waste of resources. This amount in question (35-40K) is over 1/3 of CAR25's total annual budget, and could do a lot more for the entire community including creating a part time job to train and assist the public, getting actual working cameras, and adding technologies for live broadcasts and streaming.

    ReplyDelete
  16. The cable franchise bill only does one thing. It increases the cost of cable TV for Racinians who have cable. It's just another way to extract money form people in away that they have no way to fight it.
    Just look at your water bill, phone bill, electric bill, gas bill, cable bill, cell phone bill, oil change bill, new tire bill, sewer bill, etc. and see all of the taxes that have been stuck in these by politicians who claim to be looking out for the average American. The pilfering of America continues and many Americans are too blind to event see it let alone resist.

    ReplyDelete
  17. ANON: Where does the money come from to run this cheesy programming? There is no such thing as free lunch (CAR 25). You have to take moneyt from somebody to pay for this.

    ReplyDelete
  18. anon 9:44 Or you could just not take money from anyone, and not pay for it. I'm sure it would bother the 4 people who watch CAR.

    I am also certain that those few shows that people do watch - the 4th parade, the prom - could be paid for by local sponsors who would welcome the opportunity to advertise to those audiences.

    I am also certain that those groups who want to make videos available to the community can do so, with or without CAR25. Millions do it every day - ever hear of youtube? Somehow, everyone from kids to grandmas can put together everything from news shows to how-to videos without a dollar of taxpayer funding.

    ReplyDelete
  19. I vote for equipment. Consultants rarely result in anything but some advice that you can't afford to implement anyway.

    The equipment on the other hand will surely be put to use.

    ReplyDelete
  20. I cannot watch CAR 25 because I don't get cable. I would like to see the city make it available online.

    I vote for equipment. Get the word out that we are looking for programming and let people submit ideas. Consultants are a waste.

    Most cities are cutting back on big purchases. Not us we are buying recycle carts and hiring consultants. What a mess.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Another glaring example of how Dickert is totally unqualified to run this city. NO TO CONSULTANTS, It has not worked in the past! CAR25 as a cable access channel runs great now, I as a community resident would like to see the equipment. Keep up the great work CAR25!

    ReplyDelete
  22. "used to hire consultants to create the informational videos."

    Someone please tell John Dickert that CAR 25 belongs to everyone in the City and does not exist top promote him or his cronies.

    ReplyDelete
  23. Here is an idea. Why not put Car25 on the Internet? Then everyone wins. Those who have Time Warner's Road Runner would have local programming available to their subscribers in addition to their cable service. Sounds like a natural extension to me. It shouldn't cost much to implement either. Let's get progressive.

    ReplyDelete
  24. Some of the new equipment that was originally proposed would do just that - allow CAR25 to stream everything online including archives, which makes CAR25 accessible to anyone with an internet connection, and also available to AT&T U-Verse subscribers.

    ReplyDelete
  25. 5:34

    Sounds like a good and sensible solution to me. I think most people could support that as opposed to consatans.

    ReplyDelete
  26. John Dickert = Joseph Goebbels

    ReplyDelete
  27. Internet? No way. Those freeloaders are killing the newspapers this way, so make them pay!

    ReplyDelete
  28. by gawd Anon 10:39 PM, you are so right. Look how many horse and buggy businesses those car factories put out of business. It is the same thing. Terrible, just awful. Keep those newspapers at all costs.

    ReplyDelete
  29. Why does the city need to host its own videos, when they could just put them on youtube for free? More and more businesses are getting away from owning their own IT hardware, and we're going in the other direction? Why?

    A step further: With low cost video cameras, open source video editing software, etc there are many many people doing videos. None of them require the assistance of government. Why do Racine residents need all these resources?

    Want to make a video? Buy a $200 camera, google "video editing", and you're in business - no tax $ required.

    ReplyDelete
  30. This mayor is ridiculous! Why the hell would you market Racine to Racine?? And Also, I have seen all these types of videos on CAR25 already and everything looks just fine! This reeks of some back door dealings and political pay-offs! Dickert must go!

    ReplyDelete
  31. The useless programming of CAR25 is funded through a TAX - also known as the telecom franchise fee that is 5% of the amount charged (exclusive of taxes) by TWC and ATT U-Verse. Those funds are transferred to the municipalities for their utilization. The City of Racine has chosen to use these funds for CAR25 programming. Other municipalities use the funds to offset the taxpayer’s real property bills, or returning the original tax to the tax payers. I know that is radical to most elected officials but not all.

    ReplyDelete
  32. This is just irresponsible spending. We have 35K so lets spend it quick before we have to give it back. The fastest way to get rid of the money is call up a consultant. Oh brother.

    ReplyDelete
  33. So the budget for CAR25, which accounts for all the property taxes paid by around 40+ homeowners this year, was increased by 43%

    They raised the budget,during a recession when almost 20% of those taxpayers are out of work, and probably worried about whether they will even be able to keep their homes.

    ReplyDelete
  34. Another government piglet (like public television) that should be removed from the nipple.

    ReplyDelete
  35. Eliminate the fee and let the high school students make the TV programming. I have seen what some of the students work and it is much better than what is currently on CAR25. How many of these types of channels do we really even need? Unified has their own, the city has their own, and hardly anyone watches them (but we sure pay for them)!

    ReplyDelete
  36. My whole family watches all the Common Council Meetings and our church also belongs to the channel. We like alot of the positive programming on the channel.

    ReplyDelete
  37. What you idiots fail to realize is that CH.25 also keeps most of those in city hall accountable! Watch the common council meetings every week, those are invaluable! Besides, if you don't have TW, you don't pay a thing. Keep up the good work CH.25!

    ReplyDelete
  38. There is a third option: this money will be spent on selling John Dickert and help him get reelected.

    ReplyDelete
  39. 9:48

    I think that John Dickert will use Car 25 to sell himself to the sheep for reelection. How else can his 10 year plan of more money, more money, more money, work?
    Dickert must as well the lap dogs like Helding must go.

    ReplyDelete
  40. You people are all pathetic little whinners.

    ReplyDelete