December 4, 2007

Health insurance costs more in Racine than most of state

Health insurance costs more in Racine than almost everywhere else in Wisconsin.

Milwaukee and Racine tied for second place in the cost rankings prepared by Citizen Action of Wisconsin, in a report released today. Actually, Racine moved down a notch "due to the additon of a new qualified health plan." Last year the city was the most costly in the state.

"The results very much distress me," said Mayor Gary Becker, in a statement read by William Altizer, coalition director of Americans for Democratic Action. "I am asking the Legislature to get to work on this problem, and pass real health care reform this session."

This year, the most costly region to buy health insurance is several metro areas in Western and Northwestern Wisconsin -- Eau Claire, Chippewa Falls, River Falls/Hudson and Superior -- in part because the city of Eau Claire was hit with a 57% increase in its 2008 rates.

The study found that health insurance in Milwaukee/Racine costs 25% more than in the state's least expensive city, Madison.

Monthly premium for single coverage here is $622.58, vs. $499.68 in Madison. Monthly premium for family coverage is $1,552.78, vs. $1,245.50. "This amounts to almost a $4,000 annual difference in the cost of a family policy and over a $1,500 difference in the cost of a single policy for the same benefits package," the report states. Racine/Milwaukee costs are almost 10% higher than the state average.

"This is an ongoing concern," said County Board Supervisor Diane Lange. "We are at a competitive disadvantage in our economy affecting workers and employers."

Juan Ruiz, of Voces de la Frontera, said, "A lot of poor people in the community have to decide: to eat or to buy their medicine."

The figures were obtained by analyzing the 2008 rates paid by the State of Wisconsin's Group Health Insurance Program. In 2006, the program covered over 194,000 individuals, including state employees, state retirees, some local government employees and retirees, and their immediate families and dependents.

Some other findings:

-- A November 2007 annual survey by Mercer Health & Benefits LLC found Wisconsin health insurance costs 23% above the national average ($1,868 more per employee).

-- Wisconsin health insurance costs increased 1-3% faster than the national average in 2007.

-- According to an actuarial analysis by the Lewin Group, Wisconsin health care costs will nearly double in the next 10 years, from $18.5 billion in 2007 to $35 billion in 2017.

-- "Managed competition" between health plans, in combination with large buying pools -- as proposed in the Senate's Healthy Wisconsin plan -- may place downward pressure on health care coverage costs.

-- In 1979, 73% of Wisconsin workers had health insurance through their jobs, but by 2005 the share had dropped to 58%.

The report was written by Robert Kraig, Ph.D., of Citizen Action of Wisconsin.


  1. "Juan Ruiz, of Voces de la Frontera, said, "A lot of poor people in the community have to decide: to eat or to buy their medicine.""

    Actually, part of the problem is that way too many people, especially those here illegally, use medical services, and the bills are passed along to the rest of us who have insurance.

  2. Oh - So this putting us at a competitive disadvantage is bad - but everything else Lange does, like trying desperately to raise our taxes, which also puts local employers at at competitive disadvantage, is good.

    Want to help the city of Racine? Cut Lange's full time position. She spends so much of her city time doing her part-time county job that nobody would notice she was missing.

  3. Diane Lange runs an important program that supports pregnant teenage girls - a population that is greatly underserved in Racine compared to Kenosha. She would be greatly missed.

    She is also a dedicated County Board supervisor. Agree or disagree with her views, Lange works hard to represent her constituents.

  4. Father of three12/05/2007 10:08 AM

    Well said Mr.Block!

    Helathcare is so important we all need access to affordable healthcare with the price going up every year I dont know how I can keep my family plan. This is so bad I wish people start taking this serious in Racine. Thank you Americans for Democractic Action for keeping this on the for front keep up the good work.

  5. There has to be a way to manage care and get costs down. Other countries pay less for prescriptions than U.S. citizens do. It's all a big mystery.

  6. I've always wondered why health insurance carriers offered a low co-pay. That seems to only encourage people to go to the doctor for little sniffles, colds and flu's. Sometimes adults need to take the over the counter medicine and let an illness work its way through.

  7. It is true also that some Insurance companies are unfair but there are some also Insurance companies are truly there to help citizens get affordable health Insurance.

    1. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

  8. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.